Welcome to Water Star Grille

“ Went to Water Star Grille for our anniversary dinner. The views on the back patio are phenomenal! Even with cloudy weather, it was a gorgeous restaurant. We ordered the calamari which was so yummy. Love the chili sauce on the side! Dinner was the bbq salon which is also amazing. The only disappointment was my drink. The display didn't seem worth $19, it was yummy other than the price. ”

Meg H.

“ The atmosphere + vibes was a 10/10. The food was ok but worth it for the views. The service was good too! ”

Gigi D.

“ Dearest Gentle reader, a spectacular view was in order for a very special lunch desired by one of mine tiny members of the household. I was not warmly welcomed by a hostess beginning with the letter B. As she sat my table down, I had a simple request and was told by this young lady to ask someone else or to do it myself. Cold is an understatement. However, I will say this... very quickly after, a gentleman by the name of Martin was very swift and accommodating which made that cold treating quickly forgotten. Our waitress Shannon was a delight as well while giving us some splendid recommendations in which we did not regret. I thank these two lovely people for making the experience better afterwards. Yours truly, Lady Whistledown (critic) ”

Lady W.

“ Spectacular day on the water down at Cape May, beautiful! Stopped by boat for some drinks and apps, bartender was great! Martinis and Lobster nachos. Nothing wrong with that! ”

Chris C.

“ Looking at the previous reviews for the Water Star Grill I am pretty surprised! I had a wonderful experience here for a Monday morning after Fourth of July brunch! We were a group of 4 walking around Stone Harbor around 10:30am. As most people know that come to the area, it can be difficult to find a place where you're seated right away, especially the week of July 4th! We arrived to the Water Star Grill at the back of the Reeds Hotel and we were greeted by a warm and welcoming hostess. She asked if we preferred to sit in the shade or sun and accommodated accordingly and immediately. Our waitress greeted us at the table shortly after we sat down to get our drink order. Our drinks came out in a timely manner. We had two people in our party with nut allergies, myself being one of them, and they were highly accommodating to this. The food came out after the food in again a timely fashion. Our waitress was attentive and polite, greeting us with a smile even when the restaurant was quite busy. The food was delicious and warm. I enjoyed the Santa Fe skillet which was delicious. Perfect mix of spice and flavor with the potato casserole being a unique addition to the dish. Everyone I was with also enjoyed their meals, the American breakfast, the country omelette and the eggs Benedict. We all split the brioche French toast, which I would highly recommend for a sweet treat! The view of the bay was such a nice added bonus and perfect spot for brunch. I would absolutely return here! ”

Abbey L.